Knitting vs Crochet: Which Should You Learn First?
Honest comparison of knitting and crochet on difficulty, speed, projects, and feel. Which is easier for beginners, and which is right for what you want to make.
On this page9 sections▾
The short answer to knitting vs crochet is: crochet first if you've never done either, knitting first if you have specific projects in mind that only knitting does well. The reasons take about five minutes to explain, which is shorter than most articles on this question.
What's actually different between them
Knitting uses two needles and keeps every stitch of the current row live on the needles at once. Drop one and the whole column can unravel until you catch it. The fabric is smooth, stretchy, and drapes well.
Crochet uses one hook and keeps exactly one stitch live at a time. The previous stitches are locked in place; a mistake doesn't cascade. The fabric is denser, stiffer, and holds three-dimensional shapes well.
That single-loop versus many-loops difference cascades into every other comparison below.
Which is easier for beginners
Crochet, by a real margin. Three reasons:
- Recovering from mistakes is not traumatic. You pulled out four stitches and now you have one loop on the hook? Insert the hook and keep going. In knitting, a dropped stitch can ladder down ten rows, and recovering it requires a separate technique (laddering back up with a crochet hook, ironically).
- The first usable object comes faster. A crochet dishcloth in worsted weight takes 3 to 5 hours. A knit garter-stitch scarf takes 10 to 20. Both are flat rectangles of one stitch; the difference is that crochet stitches are taller and cover more ground per row.
- Hand coordination is one-sided. Crochet is mostly the dominant hand. Knitting requires both hands to coordinate from stitch one. The Continental versus English style debate exists because two-hand coordination has multiple equally valid solutions.
The knitting learning curve isn't bad. It's just steeper than crochet's. If you're patient, knit. If you want a finished thing this week, crochet.
Which is faster once you know it
Knitting, slightly, on stitch-for-stitch comparison. Each knit stitch involves fewer hand motions than each crochet stitch.
Crochet, slightly, on row-for-row comparison. Crochet stitches are physically taller, so a row of double crochet covers more vertical distance than a row of knit stockinette.
In practice, the difference is small, and the variable that actually determines speed is which craft you've practiced more.
What each is structurally better at
Crochet wins:
- Amigurumi (stuffed toys). The dense fabric and the ability to shape three-dimensionally with single crochet in the round are made for this. Knit amigurumi exists but is structurally wrong for the job.
- Granny squares and modular blankets. Crochet motifs join cleanly, and you can build a blanket in pieces over years.
- Bags, baskets, and rugs. Anything that needs to hold a shape under its own weight.
- Fast big projects. Bulky-weight crochet blankets are the most efficient handmade blanket production method.
Knitting wins:
- Fitted garments. Sweaters, socks, fitted hats. The stretch and drape of knit stockinette is hard to replicate in crochet without compromise.
- Cables. Knit cables are crisp and structural. Crochet cables exist but read fuzzier.
- Stranded colorwork. Fair Isle, Scandinavian yokes, intricate two-color motifs. Crochet has tapestry crochet for similar effects but the look is denser and less refined.
- Delicate lace. Knit lace has an open, gauzy quality that crochet lace doesn't replicate.
If your goal is "I want to make a sweater I'd actually wear in public," knit. If your goal is "I want to make a stuffed animal for my niece," crochet.
Cost and gear
Both cost roughly the same to start. A starter set of either runs $10 to $20 including yarn for a first project. Yarn is the long-run cost, and it's the same yarn for both crafts. There's no money-based reason to pick one over the other.
The one gear-related caveat: socks and small-circumference garments require double-pointed needles or magic-loop circulars for knitting. That's another $10 to $15 you don't need until later. Crochet handles small circumferences with one hook and no additional tools.
The feel of it
Subjective but real.
Crochet's rhythm is hook-in, yarn-over, pull-through. A faster cadence with more individual hand motions per stitch. Some people find this energizing; others find it fidgety.
Knitting's rhythm is the click-click of needles and a smaller motion per stitch. Quieter, slower-feeling, more meditative. Some people find this calming; others find it slow.
Watch a video of someone doing each (any beginner tutorial works) before you buy supplies. Whichever cadence makes your shoulders relax is the one to start with.
Specific scenarios
You want to make stuffed animals. Crochet.
You want to make a sweater for your partner. Knit.
You want a meditative hobby for podcasts and evenings on the couch. Either, but knitting fits the meditation framing better.
You have arthritis or hand mobility issues. Crochet. The motions are larger and less repetitive than knitting's small wrist movements, and most crocheters use less hand strength.
You're trying to make a Christmas gift this month. Crochet. The faster learning curve plus the faster project completion fits the deadline.
You loved your grandmother's knitting and want to learn the craft she did. Knit. The connection to the craft is worth more than any difficulty advantage crochet has.
You can't decide. Crochet first. If you finish one project and want more challenge, learn knitting next. Most people who end up doing both started this way.
You can learn the other one later
The honest reason to start with one rather than agonize is that learning the second craft is dramatically easier than the first. The first craft teaches you how patterns work, how yarn behaves, how to read finished fabric, how to fix mistakes. The second craft just teaches you the new mechanics. People who already know one of the two crafts pick up the other in a few hours of practice.
So the decision matters less than it feels like. Pick the one that fits the project you actually want to make first.
For yarn weight conventions you'll encounter in either craft, the Craft Yarn Council's yarn weight system is the universal reference.
Related guides
More from the HoneyBee blog
Pattern round-ups, tutorials, and crafting inspiration from the HoneyBee community.
Read more articles